You Would Have Fired
This Advisor Years Ago.

Suppose you hired someone to manage your money. And quarter after quarter, their predictions did not pan out. The downturn they warned you about never came. The safe bet they steered you into cost you the growth you would have had. The risk they said would ruin you turned out fine for everyone who took it.

At some point, and not a very distant one, you would stop letting them decide where your money goes. You would thank them, let them go, and find someone whose record you could live with. You would not agonize over it. It is what you do with advisers who are wrong.

There is a voice in you that has held that job your whole life.

It is the one that says the client will leave if you hold the price. That the team cannot handle it if you step back. That the board will lose confidence if you say what you actually think. That this is the quarter it all comes apart. It speaks with total authority, it arrives before you have thought anything, and it has been making the calls on your behalf for as long as you can remember.

Here is what it was hired for. A long time ago, something happened that a much younger version of you could not survive without warning. So a system formed, with one job: never let that happen again. Watch for it. Warn early. Steer away. That system was built to keep a small child safe, and it did.

It is still making the same calls, at the same volume, on behalf of an adult whose life no longer needs that kind of guarding. And its record for predicting outcomes, when you actually look at it, is terrible.

You have never fired it for one reason. You have never looked at the record.

Every warning it has ever given you has been experienced in the moment, obeyed or not, and then forgotten. Nobody wrote down what it predicted next to what actually happened. So it has never once been held to account, which is a courtesy you extend to no one else who makes decisions in your company.

So start the record. A page, five columns. What it warned you about. What it told you to do. What it said would happen if you did not. What you actually did. And what actually happened. Fill in the first three every time it speaks. Fill in the last two later, honestly, including the rows where you obeyed.

Read it back in a month. You will find the same handful of warnings on repeat, in different costumes, and you will find that the outcomes it promised mostly did not arrive.

That is not a promise from a book. That is a page in your own handwriting. And once you can see the calls next to the results, you start to wake up to what you have been doing, which is handing one of the most important jobs in your life to an adviser you would never keep if it were only your money.

Back to all articles